British Political Data

ILR changes: the earned settlement rules

The standard wait for indefinite leave to remain (ILR) on work visas will rise from 5 to 10 years under earned settlement, according to the Home Office (A Fairer Pathway to Settlement: Government Response to the Consultation (CP 1707), published 2 November 2026). No start date had been set when we checked on 4 November 2026.

Share
5 → 10 yearsStandard wait for ILR on work visas, before and after
73%of 202,241 individual consultation responses came from current visa holders
1.9 millionpeople the Home Office expected to settle in 2026–2030 with no changes (central estimate)

How ILR rules change under earned settlement

ILR lets someone live in the UK for good, with no visa to renew. It is usually the step before British citizenship. Today the application costs £3,226 per person (Home Office fees table), plus £50 for the Life in the UK test.

Before: GOV.UK ILR guidance and long residence. After: A Fairer Pathway to Settlement: Government Response to the Consultation (CP 1707), page shown.
RuleBeforeUnder earned settlementPage
Standard wait on work visas5 years for most work visas (3 years for Innovator Founder and Global Talent)10 years by default, for people earning at least £12,571 a year in 5 of the last 7 yearsp.11
Faster routesNone based on earnings5 years if earning £50,271+ in 3 of the last 5 years, or in eligible health or education jobs. 3 years if earning £125,141+ in 3 of the last 4 yearsp.11, p.42
Partners and parents of British citizens5 years5 years (unchanged)p.13
Claimed benefits (specified public funds) in the last 5 yearsNo extra wait on most routes20 yearsp.14
Overstayed or broke visa conditions as an adultNo set extra wait20 yearsp.9
Entered the UK illegallyNo set extra wait10 years added to any routep.34
Refugees5 years5 years via safe and legal routes; 20 years on Core Protection; 30 years after illegal entryp.33–34
10-year long residence routeOpen: 10 years of lawful residence on any visaClosed; time on Student or Graduate visas will not countp.19–20
EnglishB1 (about GCSE level)B2 (about A level) for everyonep.17
Criminal recordAssessed case by caseAny adult with a UK criminal record is refusedp.8

Children, people aged 65 or over and people with a physical or mental condition that stops them working are exempt from the earnings rule (CP 1707, p.11). Couples can combine incomes to reach £25,142 (p.13).

What changed after the consultation

  • Cuts for volunteering were dropped. (CP 1707, p.15)
  • A 15-year wait for jobs below degree level (RQF 6), including care work, was dropped. These workers go on the 10-year route. (CP 1707, p.38)
  • Care workers who were on the route before the May 2025 White Paper keep a 5-year route if they meet the salary, sponsorship and job rules. (CP 1707, Chapter 8)

ILR reform timeline

  1. The immigration White Paper proposes raising the standard wait for settlement from 5 to 10 years, with shorter waits for people who contribute more. Source
  2. At Labour conference, Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood says settlement will depend on work, National Insurance, no benefits, good English and a clean record. Source
  3. The Home Office opens the earned settlement consultation, A Fairer Pathway to Settlement. It closes on 12 Feb 2026. Source
  4. New Immigration Rules (HC 1691) raise the English needed for settlement to B2 for main applicants who apply from 26 Mar 2027. Source
  5. The government publishes its response and the consultation analysis, and Mahmood makes a statement to the Commons. Source

The response gives no start date and no rule change has been laid before Parliament yet. It says guidance and a full impact assessment will come before the rules start.

Who answered the ILR consultation

The consultation had 202,241 responses from individuals and 2,426 from organisations, plus 904 by email. 73% of individuals (146,655) said they were current visa holders: the people whose wait for ILR the reform changes. 84% of individuals disagreed with the changes.

Individual responses by immigration status. Table 1 of Earned Settlement: Public Consultation analysis (IFF Research for the Home Office), published 2 November 2026.
Immigration statusResponsesShare
Current visa holder146,65573%
British citizen35,41218%
Settled status (ILR or EU settled status)9,2885%
Refugee or humanitarian protection5,8253%
Applying for UK immigration status or awaiting a decision2,1841%
Asylum seeker1,0741%

Consultation respondents by ethnic group, compared with the census

19% of individual responses came from White respondents. At the 2021 census, 81.7% of residents of England and Wales were White. Asian respondents made up 51% of responses, against 9.3% of residents.

Share by ethnic group: consultation respondents and residents

  • Consultation respondents (UK, 2026)
  • Residents, Census 2021 (England and Wales)
White19%81.7%
Asian or Asian British51%9.3%
Black or Black British12%4.0%
Mixed or Multiple3%2.9%
Other ethnic group8%2.1%
Respondents: Table 2 of the consultation analysis (base 202,241). Residents: Census 2021, TS021 Ethnic group, England and Wales.
Ethnic groupRespondentsShare of respondentsShare of residents (2021)
White38,91219%81.7%
Asian or Asian British103,58451%9.3%
Black or Black British24,35212%4.0%
Mixed or Multiple5,5383%2.9%
Other ethnic group16,7588%2.1%
Not stated13,0976%—
  • Anyone could answer the consultation. The Home Office analysis says the results are not representative of the public and were not weighted to match the population.
  • The consultation covered the whole UK; 86% of individual respondents lived in England. The census figures are for England and Wales only, because Scotland and Northern Ireland run their own censuses.
  • "Not stated" is our sum: the 202,241 total minus the five groups the analysis lists.

Net migration since 2021 and why the reform was tabled

Net migration was 2.5 million across 2021 to 2024, according to ONS long-term international migration estimates. That compares with about 229,000 a year from 2016 to 2019. It peaked at 891,000 in 2022.

Net migration to the UK, year ending December, ONS (May 2026 release; 2025 provisional). Full series: UK net migration by year.
YearImmigrationEmigrationNet migration
2016772,000523,000249,000
2017752,000544,000208,000
2018825,000549,000276,000
2019788,000605,000184,000
2020662,000569,00093,000
2021947,000480,000467,000
20221,398,000508,000891,000
20231,441,000593,000848,000
20241,012,000680,000331,000
2025813,000642,000171,000

Some politicians call this rise the “Boris wave”; Robert Jenrick used the term in the Commons on 2 Nov 2026.

Visas granted in 2023, the peak year, Home Office immigration system statistics.
VisaGrantedYearSource
Health and Care Worker visas granted to main applicants146,4772023Home Office
Health and Care Worker dependants203,4522023Home Office
Student dependants143,5952023Home Office

People who arrived from 2021 to 2025 reach 5 years in the UK, the current wait for ILR, between 2026 and 2030. The Home Office estimated 1.6 million people would settle in those years (consultation, Nov 2025). Its response raises that central estimate to 1.9 million, within a range of 1.3 million to 2.2 million. It says earned settlement pushes over 500,000 of them later, bringing the estimate down to 1.4 million (CP 1707, Annex A, p.45).

Who has come to the UK since 2021

Of 5.2 million work, study, family, Ukraine and BN(O) visas issued from January 2021 to December 2025, 22% went to Indian nationals, 12% to Chinese and 10% to Nigerian. EU nationals received 5%.

Donut chart of 5.20 million visas issued from January 2021 to December 2025 by nationality: India 22%, China 12%, Nigeria 10%, Pakistan 6%, Ukraine 6%, EU 5%, United States 3%, Hong Kong 3%, Philippines 2%, Bangladesh 2%, Zimbabwe 2%, rest of world 27%.
Source: Home Office, Vis_D02, published 27 August 2026. Main applicants and dependants; excludes visitor and transit visas. See the infographic.

ONS estimates that 4.3 million non-EU+ nationals moved to the UK from 2021 to 2025, against 584,000 EU+ nationals. Since 2022 more EU+ nationals have left each year than arrived.

Long-term immigration and net migration by nationality group, year ending December. ONS, Table 1, published 21 May 2026. 2024 revised, 2025 provisional.
YearEU+ immigrationNon-EU+ immigrationEU+ netNon-EU+ net
2016465,000237,000253,00090,000
2017411,000257,000176,000114,000
2018421,000330,000170,000178,000
2019349,000368,00080,000186,000
2020316,000294,00070,000101,000
2021173,000610,00015,000522,000
2022141,0001,091,000−9,000981,000
2023103,0001,188,000−53,0001,005,000
2024 (revised)91,000780,000−63,000511,000
2025 (provisional)76,000627,000−42,000350,000
  • EU+ is the 27 EU countries plus Norway, Iceland, Liechtenstein and Switzerland. Both groups exclude British nationals.
  • Visas issued are grants, not arrivals: some people never travel, and one person can hold more than one visa over five years. EU nationals with settled status and Irish nationals need no visa, so the visa chart undercounts EU arrivals.

Lifetime fiscal impact by salary

The government's case rests on earnings: people who earn more pay more tax over their lives than they cost in public services and benefits. The Home Office estimates, using the Migration Advisory Committee's model:

Lifetime net fiscal impact of one main applicant. CP 1707, Annex B, p.48–49.
SalaryLifetime net fiscal impact
£41,700+£347,000
£50,271+£456,000
£125,141+£1,530,000

For care workers, the Home Office put the lifetime net cost of 117,000 care workers and 79,000 adult dependants at £9.5 billion (Home Office, 5 Mar 2026).

Net fiscal position by ethnic group

The ONS measures whether households pay more in taxes than they receive in benefits and public services. A household that pays more than it receives is a net contributor.

Mean net position of non-retired households, £ a year (FYE 2024 prices), by ethnic group of the household reference person, UK, FYE 2022 to 2024 combined. Benefits received minus taxes paid, so a minus sign means a net contributor. ONS ad hoc 3428, Tables 3 and 4, published 18 May 2026.
Ethnic groupMean net position95% rangeHouseholds that are net contributors
White−£6,452−£7,128 to −£5,77763.1%
Asian or Asian British+£602−£2,115 to +£3,31951.2%
Black, Black British, Caribbean or African+£4,126+£1,039 to +£7,21445.7%
Mixed or Multiple−£1,274−£9,081 to +£6,53451.1%
Other ethnic group+£2,183−£2,793 to +£7,16055.4%
Bar chart of mean net fiscal position per household by ethnic group, UK 2023/24, from ONS data.
All households, UK 2023/24. Source: ONS, Effects of taxes and benefits on household income, FYE 2023/24 (Table 23); chart by @nwnatur on X. A plus sign means a net recipient. See the infographic.
  • Only the White group (net contributor) and the Black group (net recipient) have 95% ranges that do not cross zero in the ONS table. For the other groups the survey cannot say which side of zero they are on.
  • The table covers non-retired households over three years; the chart covers all households in one year, so the figures differ. Age matters: households with children or low earnings receive more.
  • These figures are by ethnic group, not by migration status. Many people in every group were born in the UK. Neither measure is the fiscal impact of the people affected by earned settlement.

What the parties said

In the Commons statement on 2 Nov 2026 (Hansard), in our words:

One speaker per party, in the site's party order.
PartySpeakerWhat they said
LabourShabana Mahmood, Home SecretarySaid the policy is about fairness to people who come legally and contribute, and to British citizens already here.
ConservativesChris Philp, shadow Home SecretarySaid keeping a 5-year route for existing care workers goes back on what the Home Secretary had said before.
Liberal DemocratsMax WilkinsonSaid the reforms are falling apart and asked the government to publish their full economic impact.
Reform UKRobert JenrickSaid the changes risk making the 2021 to 2024 rise in migration permanent, and asked whether she would resign.
Green PartyHannah SpencerSaid letting higher earners settle faster is unfair on lower-paid workers.
Your PartyJeremy CorbynAsked why very high earners are put ahead of lower-paid care workers.
Restore Britain—Did not speak in the statement.

Related pages